Monday, November 6, 2023

Fish Chicken Pork Lamb or Beef? ...or plant based protein ?

 Claude 12.6.25

Nutritional Comparison: Basmati, Jasmine Rice & Quinoa

Values per 100g of Cooked Food (mg)

NutrientWhite Basmati RiceWhite Jasmine RiceQuinoaRanking (Highest to Lowest)
Protein2,700 mg2,500 mg4,400 mg1. Quinoa (4,400mg) >
2. Basmati (2,700mg) >
3. Jasmine (2,500mg)
Carbs28,000 mg28,500 mg22,000 mg1. Jasmine (28,500mg) >
2. Basmati (28,000mg) >
3. Quinoa (22,000mg)
Dietary Fiber400 mg400 mg2,800 mg1. Quinoa (2,800mg) >
2. Basmati (400mg) =
3. Jasmine (400mg)
Total Sugars100 mg100 mg900 mg or2001. Quinoa (900mg) >
2. Basmati (100mg) =
3. Jasmine (100mg)

Can human male body create its own collagen tissue even on pure vegan diet ?

Yes, the human male body can absolutely create its own collagen tissue on a pure vegan diet. Collagen synthesis is a natural biological process that doesn't require consuming collagen directly from animal sources.

Here's how the body makes collagen and what's needed from a vegan diet:

Collagen Synthesis Process

The body manufactures collagen from scratch using these key components:

  • Amino acids: Primarily glycine, proline, and hydroxyproline
  • Vitamin C: Essential cofactor for collagen formation
  • Other nutrients: Copper, zinc, and iron as cofactors

Vegan Sources for Collagen Production

Amino Acids for Collagen:

  • Glycine: Found in soy products, legumes, nuts, seeds, and can be synthesized by the body
  • Proline: Abundant in wheat germ, soy protein, legumes, and nuts
  • Lysine: High in legumes, quinoa, and soy (as shown in your previous amino acid comparison)

Essential Cofactors:

  • Vitamin C: Abundant in citrus fruits, berries, bell peppers, broccoli, and leafy greens
  • Copper: Found in nuts, seeds, legumes, and whole grains
  • Zinc: Present in legumes, nuts, seeds, and whole grains
  • Iron: Available in legumes, leafy greens, and fortified foods

Key Considerations

The body's collagen production naturally declines with age regardless of diet. However, a well-planned vegan diet can provide all necessary building blocks for optimal collagen synthesis. The advantage is that plant-based diets are typically rich in vitamin C and antioxidants that support collagen formation and protect existing collagen from damage.

Some vegans choose to supplement with specific amino acids like glycine or take plant-based collagen boosters, but these aren't strictly necessary if the diet is well-balanced and includes adequate protein variety from the sources you've been examining (legumes, soy, quinoa, etc.).

The human body is remarkably efficient at producing its own collagen when provided with the right raw materials, regardless of whether those materials come from plant or animal sources.

Essential Amino Acids Profile: Sardines vs Plant Proteins

9 Essential Amino Acids per 100g of Food (mg)

Amino AcidSardinesSoya BeansQuinoaBuckwheatBlack BeansChickpeasLentilsMung BeansAdzukiFava Beans
Histidine8501,097407250347329323295312338
Isoleucine1,3001,971504454445503532429453495
Leucine2,1003,309840677835861874827849891
Lysine2,4002,706766672695846823718741785
Methionine780547309172149149105149131104
Phenylalanine1,1002,122593448608645615588597531
Threonine1,2001,766421506439472432390408445
Tryptophan310591167192127115114129135142
Valine1,4002,029594678564558616558572589

Total Essential Amino Acids Summary

Food SourceTotal EAAs (mg)Protein Content (g)EAAs as % of Protein
  • Sardines
  • 11,440
  • 24.6
  • 46.5%
  • Soya Beans
  • 16,138
  • 36.5
  • 44.2%
  • Quinoa
  • 4,601
  • 14.1
  • 32.6%
  • Buckwheat
  • 4,049
  • 13.3
  • 30.4%
  • Black Beans
  • 4,209
  • 21.6
  • 19.5%
  • Chickpeas
  • 4,478
  • 19.3
  • 23.2%
  • Lentils
  • 4,434
  • 24.6
  • 18.0%
  • Mung Beans
  • 4,083
  • 23.9
  • 17.1%
  • Adzuki
  • 4,198
  • 19.9
  • 21.1%
  • Fava Beans
  • 4,320
  • 26.1
  • 16.5%

Key Observations

Complete vs Incomplete Proteins:

  • Complete Proteins: Sardines, Soya Beans, Quinoa (all 9 essential amino acids in adequate proportions)
  • Incomplete Proteins: All other legumes (limiting amino acids: methionine and tryptophan)

Highest Concentrations by Amino Acid:

  • Histidine: Soya Beans (1,097mg) >> Sardines (850mg)
  • Isoleucine: Soya Beans (1,971mg) >> Sardines (1,300mg)
  • Leucine: Soya Beans (3,309mg) >> Sardines (2,100mg)
  • Lysine: Sardines (2,400mg) > Soya Beans (2,706mg)
  • Methionine: Sardines (780mg) >> Soya Beans (547mg) - Critical limiting amino acid in plants
  • Phenylalanine: Soya Beans (2,122mg) >> Sardines (1,100mg)
  • Threonine: Soya Beans (1,766mg) > Sardines (1,200mg)
  • Tryptophan: Soya Beans (591mg) > Sardines (310mg)
  • Valine: Soya Beans (2,029mg) > Sardines (1,400mg)

Plant Protein Rankings by Total EAAs:

  1. Soya Beans - 16,138mg (exceptional plant protein)
  2. Quinoa - 4,601mg
  3. Chickpeas - 4,478mg
  4. Lentils - 4,434mg
  5. Fava Beans - 4,320mg
  6. Black Beans - 4,209mg
  7. Adzuki - 4,198mg
  8. Mung Beans - 4,083mg
  9. Buckwheat - 4,049mg

Limiting Amino Acids in Plant Sources:

  • Methionine: Severely limiting in all legumes (104-149mg vs 780mg in sardines)
  • Tryptophan: Moderately limiting in most legumes (114-167mg vs 310mg in sardines)
  • Lysine: Generally adequate in legumes, but lower than animal sources

Nutritional Strategies for Plant-Based Diets:

  • Combine legumes with grains: Lentils and beans are higher in lysine, you can obtain all nine essential amino acids by eating them with grains
  • Include complete plant proteins: Soya beans and quinoa provide all essential amino acids
  • Diversify protein sources: Rotate between different legumes and grains throughout the day

Special Considerations:

  • Soya Beans: Outstanding plant protein source, surpassing sardines in 7 out of 9 amino acids
  • Quinoa: Considered a complete protein source, which means that it provides all nine essential amino acids
  • Buckwheat: Complete protein with good amino acid balance
  • Legumes: The limiting amino acids for the samples were sulfur amino acids and try[ptophan]

Bioavailability Notes:

  • Animal proteins (sardines) generally have higher bioavailability (90-95%)
  • Plant proteins have lower bioavailability (70-85%) but can be enhanced through:
    • Proper cooking and processing
    • Combining complementary proteins
    • Adequate total protein intake

Note: Values are based on cooked/prepared foods. Dry legume values would be approximately 3x higher but are not directly comparable. Data compiled from USDA nutritional databases and peer-reviewed research.

Essential Amino Acids Profile Comparison

9 Essential Amino Acids per 100g of Food (mg)

Amino AcidBeef (Lean)Milk (Whole)Chicken BreastHen EggsPork (Lean)SalmonSardines
Histidine85095820244800780850
Isoleucine1,2001981,3506861,1001,2001,300
Leucine2,0503241,9801,0881,8502,0002,100
Lysine2,2002762,2509042,1002,3002,400
Methionine65088720392620750780
Phenylalanine1,0501591,0206809801,0501,100
Threonine1,1501491,0805561,1001,1501,200
Tryptophan28046300167270290310
Valine1,3002201,2508571,2001,3501,400

Total Essential Amino Acids Summary

Food SourceTotal EAAs (mg)Protein Content (g)EAAs as % of Protein
Beef (Lean)10,73026.141.1%
Milk (Whole)1,5553.445.7%
Chicken Breast10,77031.034.7%
Hen Eggs5,57412.644.2%
Pork (Lean)10,02025.739.0%
Salmon10,87025.442.8%
Sardines11,44024.646.5%


Key Observations

Highest Concentrations by Amino Acid:

  • Histidine: Sardines (850mg) and Beef (850mg)
  • Isoleucine: Chicken Breast (1,350mg) and Sardines (1,300mg)
  • Leucine: Sardines (2,100mg) and Beef (2,050mg)
  • Lysine: Sardines (2,400mg) and Salmon (2,300mg)
  • Methionine: Sardines (780mg) and Salmon (750mg)
  • Phenylalanine: Sardines (1,100mg) and Beef/Salmon (1,050mg)
  • Threonine: Sardines (1,200mg) and Beef/Salmon (1,150mg)
  • Tryptophan: Sardines (310mg) and Chicken (300mg)
  • Valine: Sardines (1,400mg) and Salmon (1,350mg)

Complete Amino Acid Profile Rankings:

  1. Sardines - Highest total EAAs (11,440mg) with excellent balance
  2. Salmon - Second highest (10,870mg) with strong methionine content
  3. Chicken Breast - Third (10,770mg) with high isoleucine
  4. Beef - Fourth (10,730mg) with strong leucine and lysine
  5. Pork - Fifth (10,020mg) with good overall balance
  6. Hen Eggs - Moderate (5,574mg) but excellent bioavailability
  7. Milk - Lowest absolute amounts (1,555mg) but highest percentage of protein

Special Considerations:

  • Fish (Salmon & Sardines) excel in methionine and overall EAA density
  • Chicken Breast has the highest isoleucine content
  • Milk has the highest proportion of EAAs relative to total protein (45.7%)
  • Eggs provide excellent amino acid balance despite moderate total amounts
  • Red meats (Beef & Pork) show strong leucine and lysine profiles

Bioavailability Factor:

While absolute amounts are important, eggs and milk proteins have superior bioavailability and amino acid utilization rates compared to other sources, making them particularly efficient protein sources despite lower absolute concentrations.




>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
For 100grams each, which has most or least iron content? 👈
Beef, pork, lamb, chicken or fish ?

 
 
  
https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Typical-iron-concentrations-in-a-range-of-meat-types-from-22_tbl1_361953496



https://www.mkuh.nhs.uk/patient-information-leaflet/good-sources-of-iron




Beef and lamb have the highest iron content followed by pork. Chicken has the less iron content, followed by fish. 👈
Note that the iron content of meat can vary depending on the cut of meat, the cooking method, and the age of the animal. Eg a 3.5-ounce cooked hamburger patty has about 2.7 mg of iron, while a 3.5-ounce cooked lamb chop has about 4.5 mg of iron.

Study of Over 1 Million People Finds Intriguing Link Between Iron Levels And Lifespan
17 July 2020
https://www.sciencealert.com/a-study-of-1m-people-finds-a-strange-link-between-iron-levels-and-long-life

"...Put simply, having too much iron in the blood appeared to be linked to an increased risk of dying earlier."👈 

Is fish a better source of nutrition than red meat such as beef, lamb, chicken or pork ?

Yes, fish is generally considered to be a better source of nutrition than red meat such as beef, lamb, or chicken or pork. This is because fish is typically lower in saturated fat and calories, and higher in protein, omega-3 fatty acids, and vitamin D.

Here is a comparison of the nutritional content of a 3.5-ounce (100-gram) cooked serving of various types of meat:

MeatCaloriesProteinSaturated fatOmega-3 fatty acidsVitamin D
Atlantic salmon20625 grams4 grams1.2 grams573 IU
Chicken breast16531 grams3 grams0.2 grams3 IU
Beef chuck roast25026 grams10 grams0.1 grams2 IU
Pork chop25026 grams8 grams0.1 grams2 IU

As you can see, salmon is the most nutritious type of meat, followed by chicken breast. Beef chuck roast and pork chops are the least nutritious types of meat.

Fish is also a good source of other nutrients, such as selenium, iodine, and vitamin B12. These nutrients are important for overall health and well-being.

The American Heart Association recommends eating two servings of fish per week, especially fatty fish such as salmon, tuna, and mackerel. Fatty fish are particularly high in omega-3 fatty acids, which have been shown to reduce the risk of heart disease, stroke, and other chronic diseases.

If you are looking for a healthier alternative to red meat, fish is a good option. It is a nutrient-rich food that can help to improve your overall health.
Why is lamb and beef termed red meat whilst turkey, pork, chicken and fish are not ?   

Meat is classified as red or white based on its myoglobin content. Myoglobin is a protein that stores oxygen in muscle tissue. Red meat has more myoglobin than white meat, which is why it has a redder color. Myoglobin is important for muscle function, as it helps to deliver oxygen to the muscles during exercise. However, myoglobin can also break down into compounds that are harmful to the body, such as N-nitroso compounds (NOCs). NOCs have been linked to an increased risk of cancer. Red meat, such as beef and lamb, is typically higher in myoglobin than white meat, such as chicken and turkey. Pork is classified as red meat, but it has less myoglobin than beef and lamb. The following table shows the myoglobin content of different types of meat: | Meat | Myoglobin content (mg/100g) | | Beef | 8.0 | | Lamb | 7.5 | | Pork | 5.5 | | Chicken | 4.0 | | Turkey | 3.5 | As you can see, beef and lamb have the highest myoglobin content, followed by pork. Chicken and turkey have the lowest myoglobin content. It is important to note that the myoglobin content of meat can vary depending on a number of factors, such as the animal's diet, age, and muscle type. For example, grass-fed beef has a higher myoglobin content than grain-fed beef. The American Heart Association recommends eating red meat in moderation and choosing lean cuts whenever possible. It is also important to cook red meat at low temperatures to minimize the formation of NOCs. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The terms "red meat" and "white meat" are used to classify meat based on its myoglobin content. Myoglobin is a protein that stores oxygen in muscle tissue. Meat that has more myoglobin is considered red meat, while meat that has less myoglobin is considered white meat.

The following factors can affect the myoglobin content of meat:

  • Animal type:
    Some animals, such as cattle and sheep, naturally have more myoglobin in their muscles than other animals, such as poultry and fish. This is because these animals rely on their muscles for sustained activity, such as grazing and running.

  • Muscle type:
    Muscles that are used more often, such as the leg muscles of a chicken, have more myoglobin than muscles that are used less often, such as the breast muscles of a chicken.

  • Diet: Animals that eat a diet that is high in protein and low in fat tend to have more myoglobin in their muscles.

  • Age: As animals get older, their muscles tend to have more myoglobin.

Red meat is typically higher in saturated fat and cholesterol than white meat. However, red meat is also a good source of protein, iron, zinc, and other nutrients.

The following table ( moved to above) shows the myoglobin content of different types of meat:

As you can see, beef and lamb have the highest myoglobin content, followed by pork. Chicken and turkey have the lowest myoglobin content. Fish is considered to be a white meat because it has a very low myoglobin content.

It is important to note that the terms "red meat" and "white meat" are not scientific terms. They are culinary terms that are used to classify meat based on its color.

Here are some tips for choosing and preparing red meat:

  • Choose lean cuts of red meat, such as flank steak, eye round steak and top sirloin steak.
  • Trim away any visible fat before cooking.
  • Cook red meat at low temperatures to prevent the formation of harmful compounds. A.L.E., A.G.E.)
  • Eat red meat in moderation ie no more than once a week.




No comments:

Post a Comment